Good Dog Bad Dog

I came across a comic strip called “Explaining the Transgender Experience.”

It starts off with: “Let’s say that on the day you were born, someone put you in a dog costume and everyone believed you were a dog.”

The illustrations in the comic depict the person-in-dogsuit being reprimanded for not acting the way dogs are supposed to act. The “owner” scolds the dog for walking on two legs, eating potato chips; other dogs freak out when the person-in-dogsuit is nice to a cat. The tearful person-in-dogsuit is upset and runs away, goes to a mirror and realizes that they weren’t just bad at being a dog – they were a person the whole time!

What was completely absent from this comic explaining the transgender experience was any sense of bodily dysphoria, anything about perceptions of having a mismatched brain and body, anything having to do with an internal hormonal imbalance. The only cause of stress and upset coming from this comic strip was others’ ridicule of their role-violating behavior. As far as can be inferred from the comic, if the people had gone “Cool! A talking dog!” or “Aww, look at the dog eating potato chips,” there would be no tearful fleeing and a big reveal.

This comic strip wasn’t about an internal conflict; it was about a person failing to live up to the roles and expectations that everybody had for them. The comic ends not with the character rising up and challenging peoples’ previous conceptions about what dogs can do, but in concluding that they were the opposite of what society thought they were.

Imagine that this were a children’s book.

What would be the lesson?

If you don’t act like how society expects dogs to act, you’re probably not a dog.

If you like things society expects only humans to like, you’re probably a human.

If you don’t act like how society expects men to act, you’re probably not a man.

If you like things society expects only women to like, you’re probably a woman.

About these ads
This entry was posted in Discrepancies and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Good Dog Bad Dog

  1. girlsoftheinternet says:

    The irony is that that comic strip depicts the restrictive and damaging nature of gendered expectations on women rather well.

  2. bartscrivner says:

    Plus the other big thing–you can take off the dog suit. No surgery necessary,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s